All articles

AI search

When AI recommends a competitor, what should you investigate?

A practical way to review the prompt, the answer, the cited sources and the content gap behind it, while treating what you saw as a sample.

The Cura team · · 3 min read

You ask an AI engine a question your customers might ask, and it recommends a competitor. The natural reaction is alarm. A more useful one is curiosity, because the answer usually shows you why.

Work through it in four steps.

1. The prompt

Start with the question itself. Is it one a real customer would ask, in the words they would use? “Best part-time business course in Ireland” is plausible. A question built around your own product names is not.

Check too whether it is a question you could reasonably expect to appear for. If you do not offer part-time study, the competitor’s place in the answer is not a problem to solve.

2. The answer

Read what was said, not only who was named. Three things are worth separating:

  • A mention. The business appears in a list.
  • A recommendation. The answer says why it suits the person asking.
  • A citation. One of its pages is given as a source.

A competitor that is recommended and cited is in a stronger position than one that is listed. Note the reason given for the recommendation. It is often specific, such as “publishes a clear guide to evening timetables”, and that reason is your first clue.

3. The cited sources

Open the pages the answer cites. This is where most of the explanation lies.

Ask what the page does that yours does not. Does it answer the question in its opening lines? Is the information in text, or locked in an image or a PDF? Is it specific about prices, dates and requirements? Is it on the competitor’s own site, or on a directory or review site that you could also appear on?

You are not looking for tricks. You are looking for the plain reason their explanation was easier to use.

4. The content gap

Now look at your own website with the same question in mind. Usually one of three things is true:

  • You have no page that answers it.
  • You have the answer, but it is buried or hard to read.
  • You have a good page, and something technical is in the way, such as blocked crawler access or missing structured data.

If your customers ask the same question on your website, that is further evidence the gap is real, and their wording tells you how to phrase the page.

Treat it as a sample

One answer is one observation. Ask again tomorrow and the wording, the order and sometimes the businesses named can change. Answers also differ between engines, and what monitoring returns can differ from what a person sees in a consumer app.

So do not rebuild your website because of a single result. Look for a pattern across several questions and several weeks. A competitor that is cited repeatedly for the same page is a finding. A competitor named once is not.

Nor does fixing the gap guarantee a recommendation. It makes your explanation as useful as it can be, to people as well as to AI engines.

One useful action

Take one question where a competitor is cited. Open their page and yours side by side, and write down the three most specific things theirs tells a customer that yours does not. That list is your brief.

Explore Cura Visibility

Start with the questions your customers already ask.

See what Cura can help you answer and improve.